Comment on this page to sign up for the Review Committee that will support the development of consensus on the debate papers and overall conclusions.
Please use a real, working email address (which will not be published).
Signing up to participate is consent to being emailed for administrative purposes.
Anyone may comment on pages (including other than committee members), but irrelevancies or other inappropriate comments may be removed. (They will not ordinarily be deleted, so on request, text may be supplied to the email address given.) Comments may also be refactored to move them to different locations for clarity.
Participation may be anonymous, but participants are also encouraged to be open and reveal in the signup comment their real name and qualifications or affiliations. Identity and reputation do matter in science.
After signing up, participation may begin immediately. The ideal place to comment on a section of a paper is on the analysis subpage created for it.
For an example, see http://coldfusioncommunity.net/morrison-fleischmann-debate/original/ABSTRACT/
(I — Abd — have commented on the page itself. Similar comments made to that subpage, as drafts of summaries, may be copied onto the page from comments. Other comments may point out errors or other considerations.)
Until these subpages are created, such comments may be on the Original page; please identify the paper section or page involved when commenting so that it can later be moved to the appropriate subpage.
Don’t worry, if something is at all appropriate for the work or discussion, by not done “correctly,” it will be refactored. Far better for us to have wide participation, than to insist on perfect participation.